Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Aragorn's avatar

For a Stoic you seem to have an incredibly narrow definition of purpose, the ways in which man can find purpose and an even more narrow understanding of history.

Humanity spent more than 98% of its entire existence without modern economics, capitalism, defined jobs or money and we did just fine.

There are absolutely zero indications that pre historic civilisations had lower life satisfaction than modern civilisationa, quite the opposite in fact.

Prehistoric works of art from Caves in France, South Africa to Chile as well as massive earthenwork projects uncovered in Turkey, the Amazon and Russia, all indicate that massive cities already existed, where great labour forces were assembled. All within societies that actively applied administration to avoid the need for money, the acquisition of excessive wealth or power by individuals.

People led very good lives in great numbers without the modern ratrace or the belief in its necessity for progress introduced by Rousseau and his contemporaries to defend European ideas against criticism from natives and their appeal to reason during the enlightenment.

You like Geoffrey Hinton are just a doomer giving in to negativity bias and employing confirmation bias to exacerbate your disproportionate fear.

There is an equal and opposite possibility for a future that is better and far more purpose filled than anything we have today.

Most people do not enjoy their jobs, they are in effect economic slaves to their need to provide for themselves and their offspring.

Ai and Robotics can provide a future in which human labour no longer is the limiting factor in production, nor will it therefore allow to be used as a means of control anymore. We can make a future where we are all truly free, rather than slaves to promises dressed up as 'Rights' to which most of us, in practice, have no real access.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts